Stewart’s Shops ice cream is being recalled in two flavors for possible foreign material contamination in the form of metal pieces. This poses a tooth injury, mouth injury, choking, and GI tract injury hazard. The recalling firm is Stewart’s Shops Corporation of Saratoga Springs, New York.
These products were sold at Stewart’s’ Shops locations in the states of New York, Vermont, and New Hampshire. They were for sale from July 17, 2026 to October 2, 2026. These ice cream products are ready to eat and intended to be consumed at home.
The recalled products include Heavenly Medley with a best by date of February 10, 2027. The shelf life of the product is 7 months. It is sold in one half gallon paperboard cartons. The UPC number that is stamped on the label is 0 82086 44371 1. Also recalled is Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry with a best by date of February 11, 2027. The shelf life of this product is also seven months. It was sold in a one half gallon paperboard carton. The UPC number for this product is 0 82086 44377 3.
The recall was triggered when a metal object was discovered by a consumer in one of the cartons. You can see more pictures of the recalled Stewart’s Shops ice cream products at the FDA web site.
If you bought these items, do not eat them. You can throw them away in a secure trash can after double bagging them so other people can’t see them, or you can take them back to the store where you purchased them for a full refund.
